We Saw the (British) Enemy and Now It Is Us. Now What?

Brandan Buck and Andrew Day joins us to commemorate the 250th anniversary of the Declaration of Independence, and a foreign policy vision that went astray.

by | Jul 1, 2026 | News | 3 comments

When did we deviate from the Founder’s vision — that we would be a nation that would abhor imperialism and monarchy, that would not go in search of monsters to destroy (John Quincy Adams) or engage in entangling alliances that force us into overseas wars and conflicts (George Washington)?

Brandan Buck (Cato Institute) and Andrew Day (American Conservative), join Trip the Beltway Fantastic this week to grapple with the idea that the American revolution established a republic, but somewhere along the line it veered into empire — the very thing that the colonists had declared their independence from in 1776.

Some say the country was always imperialist — expanding U.S. territory, driving native peoples off lands and eventually into federal reservations. Others say ideological turns and corporatism late in the 19th Century motivated the Spanish-American war, interventions in the Western Hemisphere, the conquest of the Philippines, and that’s when it became an empire. While anti-war movements on the left and right kept this reality somewhat in check, American elites became much more cleaved to a military-first, interventionist approach, particularly after World War II, which had given Washington an impulse to pursue and preserve American hegemony.

We also discuss evangelical protestantism in the 19th century, progressivism during World War I, America First and Charles Lindberg. Smart guys and a very smart, important conversation on this auspicious anniversary. Join us!

Kelley Beaucar Vlahos is Editorial Director of Responsible Statecraft and Senior Advisor at the Quincy Institute. She was a regular news writer and reporter for Antiwar.com from 2009 to 2014. She served for three years as Executive Editor of the The American Conservative magazine, where she had been reporting and publishing regular articles on national security, civil liberties, foreign policy, veterans, and Washington politics since 2007. From 2013 to 2017, Vlahos served as director of social media and online editor at WTOP News in Washington, D.C. She also spent 15 years as an online political reporter for Fox News at the channel’s Washington D.C. bureau, as well as Washington correspondent for Homeland Security Today magazine.

Join the Discussion!

We welcome thoughtful and respectful comments. Hateful language, illegal content, or attacks against Antiwar.com will be removed.

For more details, please see our Comment Policy.